The bill was strongly opposed by the Irish Parliamentary Party (IPP), which took its obstructionism tactic to new heights by filibustering the second reading for 41 hours. Eventually the Speaker resorted to ignoring IPP MPs requesting the right of speech and put the question. This controversial unprecedented move was soon formalised when Gladstone secured an amendment of the rules of order to allow for cloture ("guillotine") motions. After the bill became law in March, The Spectator commented that it had "virtually occupied the whole time of the Lower House for seven weeks and a day; for though some part of the discussion was nominally devoted to the Queen's Speech, even that debate hardly turned upon any other subject."[7]
The act was due to expire 30 September 1882.[12][13] A bill to repeal it was defeated on first reading in February 1882, having been introduced by Thomas Sexton, a signatory of the No Rent Manifesto.[14] Forster proposed renewing the act indefinitely to deal with the crisis, but the rest of the government disagreed, and negotiations began with Parnell.[15] These lead to the "Kilmainham Treaty", which ended boycotting such that the act was allowed to expire.[15] Both Forster and the Lord Lieutenant, John Spencer, 5th Earl Spencer, resigned in May 1882.[15]
The Irish Coercion Act was important in the political development of William Morris. Up to 1881 Morris considered himself a Liberal and was the treasurer of the National Liberal League, but the Coercion Act made him irrevocably break with the Liberal Party, having come to regard its name as "only a label". This was a decisive moment in Morris' leftward development, culminating in declaring himself a Revolutionary Socialist some years later. [17]
Footnotes
^The Act had no official short title. It was referred to as Protection of Persons and Property (Ireland) Act, or with Person in the singular, and/or with (Ireland) omitted.
References
Sources
Primary
Bill for better Protection of Persons and Property in Ireland. Sessional papers. Vol. HC Bill No. 79. HMSO. 1881.
Bill for better Protection of Persons and Property in Ireland [as amended in Committee]. Sessional papers. Vol. HC Bill No. 90. HMSO. 1881.
Regulations by Lord Lieutenant under Act for better Protection of Persons and Property in Ireland. Sessional papers. Vol. HC 130. HMSO. 1881.
List of Persons detained in Prison under Act for better Protection of Persons and Property in Ireland. Sessional papers. Vol. HC 171. HMSO. 1881.
Return of Persons in Custody under Protection of Persons and Property (Ireland) Act, 1881, to March 1882. Sessional papers. Vol. HC 156. HMSO. 1882.
Letter from Captain Barlow, in Reply to Statements in House of Commons by Mr. Sexton, relative to Treatment of Persons detained under Protection of Persons and Property (Ireland) Act, 1881. Sessional papers. Vol. HC 158. HMSO. 1882.
Correspondence respecting Imprisonment in Ireland, under Protection of Persons and Property (Ireland) Act, 1881, of Naturalised Citizens of United States. Command papers. Vol. C.3193. 1882.
Secondary
Clark, Sam (September 1971). "The Social Composition of the Land League". Irish Historical Studies. 17 (68). Cambridge University Press: 447–469. doi:10.1017/S0021121400111617. JSTOR 30005304.
Jackson, Patrick (1997). Education Act Forster: A Political Biography of W.E. Forster (1818-1886). Fairleigh Dickinson Univ Press. pp. 273–275. ISBN 9780838637135. Retrieved 15 November 2016.
Orridge, Andrew W. (April 1981). "Who supported the Land War? An aggregate-data analysis of Irish agrarian discontent 1879-1882" (PDF). Economic and Social Review. 12 (3): 203–233.
Citations
^ a bLaura K. Donohue (2003). "Civil Liberties, Terrorism, and Liberal Democracy: Lessons from the United Kingdom" (PDF). In Arnold M. Howitt; Robyn L. Pangi (eds.). Countering Terrorism: Dimensions of Preparedness. MIT Press. p. 421. ISBN 978-0-2625-8239-1.
^Anne Kane (2012). Constructing Irish National Identity: Discourse and Ritual during the Land War, 1879–1882. Palgrave Macmillan. p. 220. ISBN 978-1-1370-0117-7.
^Joseph Anthony Amato (2002). Rethinking Home: A Case for Writing Local History. University of California Press. p. 4. ISBN 978-0-5209-3633-1.
^"Gladstone and Ireland". historylearningsite.co.uk.
^National Portrait Gallery, London, accessed September 2009
^"News of the Week". The Spectator (2749). London: 1. 5 March 1881.
^Simpson, Alfred William Brian (1994). In the Highest Degree Odious: Detention Without Trial in Wartime Britain. Oxford University Press. p. 4. ISBN 9780198259497. Retrieved 15 November 2016.
^ a bThe Times, Arrest of Mr. Parnell, 14 October 1881
^Aldous, Rishard; Puirseil, Niamh, eds. (2008). "'No Rent Manifesto' The Land League calls for a rent strike against landlords, 18 October 1881". We Declare; Landmark Documents in Ireland's History. London: Quercus. pp. 90–91. ISBN 978-1-84724-672-1.
^Edwards, Owen Dudley (2009). "American Diplomats and Irish Coercion, 1880–1883". Journal of American Studies. 1 (2): 213. doi:10.1017/S0021875800007866. ISSN 0021-8758.
^Protection of Persons and Property Act 1881, section 4
^House of Commons Procedure Committee (14 December 2015). "2 The House's practice". Notification of the arrest of Members. UK Parliament. fn.8. Retrieved 15 November 2016.
^"Protection of Person And Property (Ireland) Act Repeal Bill; Motion For Leave". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). 9 February 1882. pp. HC Deb vol 266 cc342–66. Retrieved 15 November 2016.
^ a b cNicholls, David (1995). The Lost Prime Minister: A Life of Sir Charles Dilke. A&C Black. p. 108. ISBN 9781852851255.
^"Statute Law Revision Act, 1894, Schedule 1". Irish Statute Book. Retrieved 15 November 2016.
"Bills Index: P". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). PROTECTION OF PERSON AND PROPERTY (IRELAND) ACT REPEAL BILL, Protection of Person and Property (Ireland) Bill, PROTECTION OF PERSON AND PROPERTY (IRELAND) BILL No. 40, PROTECTION OF PERSON AND PROPERTY (TRELAND) BILL, Protection of Person and Property Bill, Protection of Personal Property (Ireland) Bill, Protection of Persons and Property (Ireland) Arrests Bill.